#81 Ein guter Prozess auf Papier verändert noch keine Organisation. Mit Anne-Christin Hellmich, Commercial Finance Lead bei Bayer Consumer Health.
Creating Excellence in Finance - Transformieren Sie Ihren Finanzbereich
Shownotes
Anne-Christin Hellmich hat Beyond Budgeting zweimal eingeführt, mit demselben Konzept und sehr unterschiedlichem Ergebnis. Im Gespräch mit Viktor Mendel erklärt sie, warum sich eine Transformation nicht kopieren lässt und ab welchem Punkt man die Welt der Finanzprozesse verlässt und die Kultur betritt. Es geht um Beyond Budgeting, um die Trennung von Ambition, Prognose und Ressourcen, und darum, was von Finance bleibt, wenn KI Analysen und Szenarien übernimmt.
Das Gespräch ist auf Englisch, Intro und Outro auf Deutsch.
Gast: Anne-Christin Hellmich, Commercial Finance Lead bei Bayer Consumer Health in Basel. LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/anne-christin-hellmich/
Werbung SAGE:
Das E-Rechnungs-Kit: 7 Ausreden + die Lösung, kostenloses E-Book (Fristen, Formate, Checkliste) und kostenlose Beratung, unter www.sage.com/cfo-podcast
Transkript anzeigen
00:00:00: I observed this now quite heavily.
00:00:02: I think, fifteen years ago everyone said okay we will need data scientists.
00:00:06: so many young people studied data science and when AI some months ago it was like ah!
00:00:12: We don't eat data scientist anymore but of course you do maybe not in the way they were trained fifteen years before But in a different manner because someone needs to understand what's happening behind or even further leverage on how we can achieve.
00:00:28: Welcome to Mendel Talks Finance, the podcast for the financial world presented by Victor Mendel.
00:00:34: The strategic management advice on excellence in finance.
00:00:40: Dear Christine!
00:00:41: A warm welcome today's podcast episode – happy to see you here!
00:00:47: Thank you, Victor.
00:00:48: I'm super excited with all of you and we've been thinking about this podcast quite a while now.
00:00:56: So before we start to the topic and start with a topic, I would like to ask you to introduce yourself.
00:01:03: What is your job?
00:01:04: what are doing And what does your passion for?
00:01:07: what are really burning?
00:01:09: so please introduce yourselves.
00:01:11: Yeah briefly on myself i'm from Berlin twenty years in the pharmaceutical industry.
00:01:17: I spent most of my career in several finance functions in germany as now Switzerland's and worked also into financial leadership roles.
00:01:26: Yes, I've been quite through a bunch of transformation in that time.
00:01:30: And yeah today i'm leading the commercial finance team for the AG's consumer health business located here in Basel Switzerland and topic and particularly passionate about is how finance can move from administering numbers to enabling really better decisions understanding beyond the typical reporting and planning and this is what we wanted to discuss.
00:01:53: so when you reached out and we thought about a topic immediately came to my mind.
00:01:57: unfortunately that lines also very well business partnering and i expect your focusing on so today beyond budgeting.
00:02:06: Is it spirit?
00:02:07: and yeah these three topics be on budgeting.
00:02:10: business partner in day I might look at when we spoke like completely different topic in topics individually, But I need to ask the same question right if finance spends less time on producing and defending numbers, how can we use this capacity.
00:02:27: To create really better decisions in outcomes by a business partner?
00:02:30: real business partnering yeah.
00:02:32: so what is about today?
00:02:34: This is your passion right
00:02:36: indeed.
00:02:37: So great.
00:02:37: so let's make it step-by-step.
00:02:40: you already said will speak of our beyond budgeting people speak up out business partnering but Let's start from zero, let's say zero-based budgeting.
00:02:52: You have also experience with zero based budgeting and maybe you can tell a little bit about what were your experiences?
00:02:58: What was behind the concept that you see on paper how easy or difficult it is to implement zero base budgeting?
00:03:08: I think the biggest lesson for me was that you can design really good process of paper instead not change the organization When you have a transformation.
00:03:17: the mechanics are actually easier part because u can define the governance and templates timelines and who makes which decision.
00:03:25: but difficult part is how your changing people's behaviors around money.
00:03:32: And people need to understand not just what process it said its designed on paper when they should behave in different way tomorrow, And they need to decide on themselves.
00:03:43: what decision am I now expected make in this new concept.
00:03:47: What am i accountable for?
00:03:48: because that also might shift?
00:03:50: and, what happens if i have two surface changes toward the original you planned?
00:03:56: we cannot expect everyone too easily and quickly adapt to this.
00:04:00: not every one is a natural talent in these changes.
00:04:03: right i think your know that sometimes we ourselves are also not natural talents in this especially not developing these new capabilities overnight.
00:04:12: It's a learning journey that benefits from time and especially real world training.
00:04:16: So no matter how good the concept is, I think you have to push people sometimes into this situation so they really learn themselves in an environment?
00:04:25: That means it doesn't matter if your concept works well or not but of course should be very good.
00:04:32: You had also experience with one company at once.
00:04:37: This concept worked well.
00:04:39: The same concept didn't work, let's say at the same way.
00:04:43: At least then in a company or environment before what are your reasons?
00:04:48: maybe you can explain it little bit more deeply?
00:04:51: Yeah I think that was one of my most humbling lessons for me.
00:04:54: if you ask me like this You can come with a tonne experience and model that has worked before an organisation that loved it.
00:05:02: so lot of conviction overall.
00:05:04: but you cannot copy and paste transformation from one organisation to another.
00:05:08: And the difference is usually not a quality of the concept as said it's an environment and you also have to acknowledge.
00:05:16: The historic background in nature after business and all.
00:05:20: so that's why we chose the title off today's podcast.
00:05:24: change the culture around.
00:05:25: yeah, this is really crucial determining factors.
00:05:29: when do you look specifically at me on budgeting?
00:05:32: ask leaders to give up some of their parents security they have today the detailed annual plan for example and ask to be transparent when it comes to reporting needs to be.
00:05:46: So often this means that we have two step away from protecting our original base not only as finance people but also as leaders, what is the truth?
00:05:56: in an unknown way?
00:05:58: let us everyone to kind of distinguish between agenda might influenced a little bit by your stick interest but to look more on an enterprise level, what benefits the overall enterprise and that might then uncover some bad truth or also positive ones for steering purposes in the past wouldn't have shown.
00:06:19: And I think it requires a lot of trust and letting go off things that gave you security in the passed?
00:06:28: That's important!
00:06:30: We have psychologically attendancy rights to punish down sides over incentivize upsides.
00:06:36: It's just human, no?
00:06:38: Which is human right?
00:06:39: but then stepping away from that and seeing this now serves a whole organization instead of yourself as the whole new world you have to tap into when want roll out your budgeting.
00:06:51: also zero based budgeting something where we have prep culture for people make them feel there.
00:06:58: enough trust in spirit helps team win which they benefit form.
00:07:05: That's a good point.
00:07:05: What you are saying now, so I think the most people when they're thinking about implementing beyond budgeting They're thinking okay We have new processes.
00:07:14: maybe we haven't used system.
00:07:16: It is may be our new budget attitude But it's much more a cultural change.
00:07:22: and then of course process has changed but that it Is accepted?
00:07:26: And the people work in this way.
00:07:28: its more cultural thing right
00:07:30: mm-hmm.
00:07:31: Yeah, i think immediately swarm more far, more than the methodology behind it.
00:07:36: Yeah?
00:07:37: The moment you ask why people create buffers while they protect resources and when they don't surface up or down side early You have left the world of these finance processes and enter the word off culture immediately.
00:07:52: a traditional budget often tries to make one number do several jobs It covers all at once can be a target forecast or resource allocation but That's where the strange behavior starts.
00:08:05: If you just boil it down to this one KPI that your pursuing, One of ideas I find most powerful in Beyond Budgeting is actually very simple and i think thats also a secret to success.
00:08:16: You have to separate these kind conversations Then move this figure level upto the culture And beyond budgeting very nicely addressed with so called ambition.
00:08:26: Ambition Is what we want to achieve.
00:08:29: A forecast still remains.
00:08:30: This is What We Think Will Happen And resource allocation is how we make it happen.
00:08:35: Yeah, so also very tangible numbers.
00:08:38: but this ambition eating is something that comes from the team within.
00:08:43: So its more philosophical thing and also a number of it has whole new rational behind them set up themselves in its not dictated from above on.
00:08:52: that's the guiding star leads you through throughout the whole year.
00:08:57: to me I'm very fascinating aspect about all concept.
00:09:00: It's more psychological instead of financial.
00:09:03: Yeah, yeah definitely and I think this is also the reason what we said in the beginning that The same concept may work In one environment but it's not working another Environment.
00:09:13: if you just see as a process If you're just seeing us new content pushing through the organization?
00:09:30: We're very much finance people here, you and me right?
00:09:32: And the community that listens to this podcast most likely will also be financed.
00:09:37: I think what is also a beauty is that finance itself it's not even the biggest benefit of all concept but its whole business in company!
00:09:47: Then i think if your are a finance person who likes to act beyond the exit file being a business partner into a community That gives more joy than to accompany Enterprise along that route.
00:10:01: So imagine you have an opportunity That you generally haven't had on the radar.
00:10:06: then if you really go beyond budgeting and look into this ambition mindset The question is not do you still has budget or Is your target already achieved for next year?
00:10:15: Can we push it maybe to another cycle.
00:10:18: but You can really ask yourself how you can use his upside.
00:10:21: benefit, the whole organization?
00:10:24: Okay Let's make it more concrete.
00:10:26: so what was the benefit?
00:10:28: for the organization to work with beyond budgeting and not with the standard budgeting process.
00:10:34: The benefit is, I think accountability.
00:10:38: if you have a really rigid budget frame that question to me it's really how much do you identify with this?
00:10:46: And how much adequate for our todays times where everything changes?
00:10:50: yeah we need to be more agile.
00:10:52: i think there is clear an annual budget does not useful anymore.
00:10:56: It changes due to what we observe in the geopolitical environment every day and every week quite massively.
00:11:03: First of all, meeting today's time needs are being more agile.
00:11:07: on the second hand I think yeah they hold their whole company then with a transparency benefits as it enables them or two win as a team.
00:11:15: if you look at the siloed budget approaches people looking there respective area And If They Have Accomplished Their Target A budget refrains them to go above and beyond if they can, which would eventually again benefit the whole company.
00:11:30: On the opposite side that have a downside then they get punished.
00:11:34: That's also not useful because instead of looking individually at their silos And how to compensate from within Opening this up into community once again and openly addressing How it could be fixed.
00:11:47: I can offer many new solutions.
00:11:50: If you are out with Beyond Budgeting or these static frames where you really make this joint exercise, I think we all know as a team.
00:11:58: You can achieve much more and then that makes the financial process also a team.
00:12:03: sport?
00:12:04: Yeah!
00:12:05: That means...I mean if you compare it to standard budgeting process now you define at once of course in moment when defined.
00:12:14: close budget is already wrong because as said environment changing nearly every day Instead of discussing from months to month, you use this beyond budgeting process in a more close and constructive discussions.
00:12:37: How do shift how to navigate?
00:12:40: And how to adjust maybe the strategy or so on.
00:12:44: absolutely that means we as finance and organization has to become much more curious when the budget is a anchor.
00:12:52: it's very easy for our questions to be calm.
00:12:55: are you just there in check my dad?
00:12:56: but how do i want to be there and such a fluctuating environment.
00:13:01: And without these static questions on a budget the question have two become much better and much deeper.
00:13:08: so what has really changed?
00:13:09: understand that the base causes better, You don't have to find excuses if you really track with more leading indicators on a specific thing.
00:13:19: So, give the example of pharmaceuticals and then stop talking just about the plain net sales number.
00:13:25: but we look at patients that are enrolling in the news prescription they're making.
00:13:30: these are much meaningful KPIs and this helps us understand better business drivers eventually right?
00:13:37: That gives also forward-looking evidence What this means for the decisions we make now and this is i think what's much more closer to business partners that you want to be.
00:13:48: I'm not only looking at a figure but the meaning behind it right.
00:13:51: eventually doesn't change about the take that finance needs financial discipline probably more than before, but discussions were having are much richer and even give better prediction opportunities for us.
00:14:05: This is really an interesting point.
00:14:07: I mean, of course business partnering also working without beyond budgeting.
00:14:12: but beyond budgeting can make it more smart because the whole system and all discussions during the year are leading to a better business partner.
00:14:23: if you consider this as
00:14:28: new
00:14:29: culture not just in your process And then it's beyond budgeting leading to a better business partnering.
00:14:37: Yeah, It can and if I think the experiment is always worth it but as you said beforehand my humbling experience sometimes doesn't work.
00:14:48: also The conditions need to be right?
00:14:50: i think You cannot enforce that If you see that the organization Is not ready.
00:14:56: But stepwise if your willing To pursue this you Can implement Step by step approach.
00:15:03: When I read first time the Beyond Budgeting book by Beate Bosniaz, who is an inventor of a concept.
00:15:09: I was like...I have to say that i was deeply disappointed at the end of my book because where's now the concept?
00:15:18: So I really expected
00:15:20: it
00:15:21: from the book step-by-step approach how to roll out and then I was very deeply disappointed.
00:15:27: Normally I don't have such strong emotion, but i was like okay great.
00:15:29: I read through all of this now and know i'm as smart As i am before But it took me quite a while until i realized actually that's the beauty around It right because he does not force you to Have one concept.
00:15:42: then only if You roll us out exactly than your doing beyond budgeting?
00:15:46: What he gives you certain aspects That you can also in a very safe Sandbox environment.
00:15:52: you Can test it out yeah with parts of organization parts of a formal budget.
00:15:58: And then it creates, you can observe what happens?
00:16:01: You create learning out of that and have people who test it out to see the benefits but not in black-and-white approach which is also fascinating aspects for testing out.
00:16:15: There's one sentence, Christine coming into my mind when I say to customer about implementing business partnering.
00:16:23: culture follows structure.
00:16:26: And beyond budgeting could be a structure, so this is our specific process.
00:16:32: to define and to live with.
00:16:34: budgeting in this structure would help.
00:16:38: good not necessarily but it will help you go through a better business partnering?
00:16:44: If we're thinking in this way then its clear also business partnering does not happen by themselves because if your just wanted us on earth new routines, new structures and your rules how to work together.
00:16:58: And beyond budgeting could be a vehicle or structure for better business partner right now?
00:17:06: Yeah I think what you said is super well done.
00:17:08: It's fluctuating.
00:17:09: as the final person You have quite strict cadences in process but nonetheless things change.
00:17:17: sometimes if they are okay their old system doesn't work anymore.
00:17:20: i think this defines finance business partners, that they then go this one step beyond by not saying yeah but it is a process and I stick to it.
00:17:29: But when you think about more creative ideas on how to improve the situation?
00:17:34: And there's just another tool set can help do so.
00:17:38: It doesn't define or dictate something
00:17:41: as well.
00:17:42: i mean y'all already said As a profit for both sides, for finances also.
00:17:49: For the business.
00:17:50: if both sides have advantage from this process and new culture or way of working then it will work.
00:17:58: otherwise its just pain in their neck.
00:18:02: people try to avoid
00:18:05: that.
00:18:06: You shouldn't force an organization into situation which makes things even worse where you lose your community.
00:18:16: But if you're at a point where the old system does not help anymore, these kind of aspects that you can implement are quite helpful to change in least certain parts.
00:18:26: This could be your right moment now and their whole system is not working
00:18:29: indeed?
00:18:31: And off course in companies were you have stable environment conditions then normal budgeting system it's maybe another bad system.
00:18:40: you define target You define a bonus set on this target and so, it's only you can work.
00:18:47: But I think in other companies when the environment is changing And if we have twenty percent more than budgeted or less then maybe not to write system anymore now.
00:18:58: Yeah i think also rolling forecast address that.
00:19:02: The question is how frequent?
00:19:04: Can you do update of forecast?
00:19:07: How much these data points will help to steal the business going forward right?
00:19:12: just more forecast?
00:19:14: and also doesn't in my experience at least.
00:19:18: That you land a year better it can be done even more of because then people are so paralyzed by looking at the numbers updating them, really forcing themselves to get the best idea how they could happen that maybe in germany we have this saying you can describe every leaf on tree but you cannot describe the wood anymore And I think that's a pretty good comparison.
00:19:41: Yeah, you're right.
00:19:42: The process or the idea by themselves could be not helpful and just spoke few weeks ago to someone.
00:19:48: she said they use their budgeting rounds during here in summer to discuss more briefly about strategy of business ambitious enough and so on.
00:20:04: So this is the typical discussions about a budget that I also knew from my past, but it's much more helpful if you discuss business opportunities and cross-selling topics like these are the same for our rolling forecast.
00:20:19: If we just do every month in your forecast to set new targets then how should work?
00:20:25: Yeah what your colleague described these kind of pulse checks where you really focus on the main business drivers.
00:20:33: You just look at the biggest effects while you keep everything with stable assumptions also is one of a more creative ways that really helps your thing to focus more and the underlying business indicators in what's happening.
00:20:48: if u look at these drivers only again i think, don't focus on just financial kpis but the more qualitative kpis behind it and what is driving them.
00:20:59: that leads them for better understanding of the organization and your finance building partner, but it also helps you to derive a better forecast on the influence in factors that determine how you land this year.
00:21:10: Yeah definitely.
00:21:13: one other question Christine if we are looking at AI and what is happening let's say nearly an daily pace Is this helpful or another pain in the neck?
00:21:27: I think for us
00:21:29: it's pretty interesting.
00:21:31: Yeah, a i will increasingly be able to produce analysis identify patterns prepare scenario and suggest recommendations.
00:21:39: so everything that we did in the past right being The person who can produce spreadsheet faster would become this differentiating for finance folks But even more so interesting.
00:21:50: So what remains incredibly valuable is?
00:21:59: It's a question we're asking the right question.
00:22:02: Does your recommendation make sense in context of business?
00:22:05: Which assumptions really matter and what I mean maybe missing out, i think differentiating competencies become really business understanding critical thinking judgment that we as finance folks can have on our organization because historically we've been trained on facilitating these discussions with commercial folks.
00:22:28: they don't necessarily have focused on that.
00:22:31: And that's what differentiating the human finance person from what the AI can do today, and this is to me I think the future of finance which makes it even more interesting because it moves you beyond this report.
00:22:46: when i look at myself analyze it pick out some findings It was all now done so we can focus on a more Interesting part.
00:22:58: And even when in the past finance was on a table for example, and they're budgeting rounds.
00:23:03: So I saw a lot of finance guys who are sitting in a budget meetings but just clicking through these lights to the figures.
00:23:14: it's not really valuable.
00:23:16: what you said is we can go much further than so bring input because we can explain the logic behind the figures.
00:23:28: this is much easier with a.
00:23:31: Yeah it's easy and then that enables us to fully focus on the discussion.
00:23:35: until that goes i mean, let me clear where most times about cops not so many other people in organization hold this position and train does also have certain way of argumenting trying to get information out off the people also creating consensus across the organization right?
00:23:55: Their different interests.
00:23:56: so I think we shouldn't underestimate here the competencies of finance folks and these competencies AI currently cannot compensate in the organization itself.
00:24:07: If they just rely on the AI outcomes would miss out on this part, so i think We must be careful not to undersell ourselves in these times but rather see the benefit that ai provides by enabling us To have more time for those And also then benefiting the organization by focusing more on these communication skills that we can provide.
00:24:28: I mean, the worst scenario would be if the finance guys are not seen anymore as axels and number crunchers.
00:24:37: they will be seen as AI nerds or something like this.
00:24:41: AI should enable finance to become more than just numbers and AI figures and axels.
00:24:50: Yeah, not that you say and actually super nice point.
00:24:53: right if you think about it.
00:24:54: We are one of the first areas where I can really compensate for a lot off the task we've been doing.
00:25:00: but instead of seeing this negatively we could also stay.
00:25:03: look.
00:25:03: We're quite advanced because we can already build some really reasonable use cases for our day to day jobs.
00:25:09: good perspective
00:25:10: yeah?
00:25:11: This is what they just have in my mind.
00:25:13: i mean finance was in their past One after less people who get worked at systems axle cracks and so on, all the sharp cuts.
00:25:25: And it would be dangerous if you were seen in the future just as an AI nerd.
00:25:30: It's great to be expert in AI.
00:25:33: I think that is extremely helpful but we should use this knowledge to go closer to business
00:25:40: now.
00:25:40: absolutely not black-and white certainly gray But its'nt necessarily important a threat.
00:25:48: First chance to ask
00:25:49: yeah
00:25:50: also many people are seeing all the risks of AI for sure.
00:25:54: that's also a very topic and yes, some work will be taken over by I think but other work remains.
00:26:03: And maybe you were talking about
00:26:06: pop up here so we should grab this opportunity buy hair because it's there now.
00:26:11: no i mean look at data scientist right?
00:26:15: I observed this now quite heavily.
00:26:17: I think, fifteen years ago everyone said okay we will need data scientists.
00:26:20: so many young people studied data science and when they are some months ago it was like ah!
00:26:27: We don't eat data scientist anymore.
00:26:29: but of course you do maybe not in the way that were trained fifteen year ago But in a different manner because someone needs to understand what's happening behind or even further leverage what can be achieved.
00:26:40: Recently i thinking Actually, it's a little bit like when Ford was inventing the mass production.
00:26:46: Right?
00:26:46: Everyone was out and then you don't have to work eight hours anymore.
00:26:49: but that is only before because we are so much more efficient than ever!
00:26:53: We never see them
00:26:53: right?!
00:26:54: Once they get more efficient... ...we will come up with new topics and accelerate even further And thats also quite exciting.
00:27:01: But there has to be let say flexible or agile or whatever.
00:27:06: So we have to adjust our competencies also To do new facts what we have?
00:27:11: No, there's so many skills we can further build on?
00:27:14: I think
00:27:15: definitely not and they have to be have two.
00:27:18: Yeah i know with a different scale in speed i think is this also one of the main aspect that people are afraid off but it can't be fun though its something unseen it creates a lot of insecurity because important let me also listen to us from what i observe in the finance organization there's a lot of insecurity as people perceive it readily as a threat.
00:27:41: and yes for people who I think are not agile or willing to go down this journey.
00:27:48: It is indeed a friend.
00:27:49: yeah because if you're still behind your exiles an other classic person who does not like to speak to people but just have numbers under control yes clearly at least afraid, unforeseen opportunities as well.
00:28:05: And taking this fear now out of the finance community and making us aware of the competencies we bring to that table, yeah I think something really crucial too keep also big finance organizations on a positive
00:28:18: mindset.".
00:28:19: And i think in a nutshell it doesn't matter if you are speaking about zero base budgeting or using off AI.
00:28:28: its more than just A process is more than just a new tool or whatever.
00:28:35: So it's always a vehicle to work better together, closer finance controlling the business This I think what we should have in mind.
00:28:48: Just be effective by themselves but not helpful.
00:28:52: But to use the time you want go closer to the business or something like this, now.
00:29:00: This is their way of thinking a thing no?
00:29:03: Yeah I mean look at how finance people are used.
00:29:07: many times they're not only one who's crunching the numbers but also advisor consignants multi-purpose weapon if you want.
00:29:14: so and looking into supply chain topics wherever someone needs you finance people normally stick then also in todays topic.
00:29:23: Also if leaders and the other functions why wouldn't they be happy about the finance person having more time for these kind of conversations in supporting them along way.
00:29:33: Great very nice discussions a lot different topics, and then it's always the same.
00:29:40: how can finance me?
00:29:43: More business partner that say
00:29:44: no need.
00:29:46: thank you bye.
00:29:48: I think quite a lot was very deep questions.
00:29:50: now on AI.
00:29:51: You got a little bit of track but actually not because as you say it's the catcher question behind everything that we discuss business partnering and also be on budgeting.
00:30:00: Great discussion.
00:30:01: i love that kristin.
00:30:03: thank u very much for this inspiration and hope to see soon again
00:30:08: absolutely all pleasure victor.
00:30:10: thanks a lot for your time,
00:30:14: In every episode we offer you deep insights into the strategies, visions and innovations that will prevail in tomorrow's financial world.
00:30:27: We hope they have gained valuable knowledge.
00:30:30: If you subscribe to Mendel Talks Finance, always stay tuned!
00:30:33: We are talking with high-ranking guests who design the future of the financial world!
00:30:39: You can find more information at VictorMendl.de.
00:30:45: Vielen Dank fürs Zuhören und bis zu unserer nächsten Folge von Mendel Talks Finance.
Neuer Kommentar